Friday, September 10, 2010

The Big Question

Everyone wants maximum comfort on a very long flight. The last thing a passenger wants is to be sitting next to what "Mail Online" votes as one of the worst kinds of passengers. This type of passenger is the morbidly obese. There have been many complaints of how a person's personal space has been invaded by these colossal beings. These complaints have started a new policy in some airlines where the morbidly obese should have to pay for two seats if they take up part of another seat. This has stirred major controversy among the morbidly obese. Their argument is that they are they are being discriminated against because they cannot control their weight due to health conditions. I believe that they should pay for an additional seat if they take up part of it.
There are two ways to deal the morbidly obese on airplanes. The airlines can either charge them for two seats or be more accommodating to the obese person's needs. Like all businesses the airline business's top priority is making money. The problem with changing the plane to accommodate the obese is that it would cost millions of dollars to re-engineer the plane and to rebuild them all. So, from a cost point of view charging them for two seats is far more effective.
 However, there is the possible cost of lawsuits filed for discrimination if the obese are charged for two seats. One obese woman even described it as a type of racism (Fat-ism). Although there are many diseases that contribute to obesity, none are the actual cause of obesity. The real cause is simply too many unhealthy foods and not enough exercise. The fact that an obese person can control their weight makes it completely different then someone who cannot control their skin color. Therefore, this is obviously not discrimination.
Another reason that the morbidly obese is a problem on airplanes is the safety hazard they create. This hazard is created if the plane is sinking and the passengers need to get out. The obese take up more room creating an incredibly inconvenient escape path for the other passengers. This inconvenience places lives in danger in an emergency.
In conclusion, the obese should be charged for two seats. This is because they take up that additional space and should have to pay for it, they create a safety hazard, and it would cripple the airline business financially to  design all their planes to accommodate to obese people. This is not discrimination because the obese can control their weight to a large degree.



Sources

"Fat-ism Worse Than Racism." CORRUPT.org: Conservation & Conservatism. Web. 11 Sept. 2010. <http://www.corrupt.org/articles/satire/alex_birch/fat-ism_worse_than_racism>.

1 comment:

  1. Clearly argued. I liked both your title and the picture. Sometimes, a picture is worth a thousand words.....except for when writing your English essays. But it certainly works here very well. Blogs are clearly meant to be multi-media.

    ReplyDelete